Jump to content

ianguygil

Advanced Member
  • Posts

    616
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ianguygil

  1. 19 hours ago, Caldera said:

     

    Well, the OP just pointed out something that I'd consider a major disadvantage: Thailand gets millions of tourists per year who can't participate in PromptPay, because they can't get a Thai bank account.

     

    Nothing to do with evading the authorities.

    Tourists can use cash or card at those few vendors who won't receive cash - like STARBUCKS - they can use a card. Even for small amounts. No country would base their decision on a strategy like trying to formalize the economy on the needs of tourists - even if a major sources of FX revenue. You can just see the huge acceptance and growth in the use of QR Codes by the Thai public to see how popular this is. We see 40% annual increase in volumes with a combination of both more customers and even more markedly each customer using the system more frequently each day largely for QR based payments.

     

    I would predict that QR will be replaced by some national or international contactless solution similar to APPLEPAY or GOOGLEPAY but without the exorbitant fees involved. Again, QR in Thailand is free. And (almost) every phone has a camera. 

     

    I would note that there are many more stores in the UK and in the USA who do not accept cash than there are in Thailand. QR is largely offered and embraced as an option with cash still welcome. In the UK that is not true 

  2. This (QR) "formalizes" the economy so that the authorities can better see the flows of funds. There is a lot behind this and it is very valuable to tax collection and for economists. It also saves cash because they spend a lot to print banknotes and to recycle. Plus the big Fraud problem on larger notes. 

     

    Also, this is convenient for poor people because it does not require them to maintain a "float of cash". Like a Noodle seller who may need to get 1,00 Baht in 20's and 1,000 in 100 Baht notes in order to make change at the start of day with cash would no longer need to so with Promptpay for most purchasers. 

     

    For people like me it means I do not have to go to the ATM - even though I do work in a bank. And it automatically gives me receipts. Which makes it easier for reimbursements. Plus paying bills and transferring is so much easier. You can display the QR code for you for Promptpay and users do not need to know your account number or phone number. And this works for Push and Pull payments. 

     

    Many benefits and almost no disadvantages I can see as long as you are not running some kind of weird business and do not want the authorities to know about income.

     

     

    • Thumbs Up 2
  3. Please give a rough idea of the amount that you plan to move. If this is over about $60,000 USD, you are better to negotiate an FX rate with us (Bangkok Bank) in Thailand. It is like buying Wholesale v Retail. Then when you send the funds it will refer to this FX arrangement and you will get that rate. But it does need to be above an certain fixed amount. Building a house varies widely in cost and I have no idea of the amount involved.

     

    If you go to a branch or to our HQ on the 2nd floor you can ask them for details. This is not complex.


    PM me if you want more details and I an refer you to the Global Payments group who will deal with you directly. Thanks

     

    It is NEVER beneficial to move a foreign currency to THB offshore in a developed country (maybe ok in Myanmar, Lao or Cambodia)

     

    Ian

    • Like 1
    • Love It 1
  4. I didn't read this whole thread so please excuse if already answered

     

    There is no need to open an account. We do offer accounts but the are not FDIC Insured. And as I said no need if you  just want to move funds. This link will help. If you still need help the please PM me

     

    Ian

    Transfer money from the US to Thailand via Bangkok Bank’s New York branch

  5. 1 hour ago, ignis said:

    Odd, maybe need to go into another Branch, my local Branch said cannot...  I took both phones into the Branch....  Samsung Android 9 and Vivo Android 10

     

    Bit confused been with Bangkok Bank 24 years !!  it did work on both phones but suddenly stopped about October last year

     

    Looked on Bangkok Website updated 20 Dec 2023.......  

    • Android 7.0 or higher required


    To enhance transaction security and application efficiency as well as support new features, upcoming Bangkok Bank Mobile Banking versions will only be supported on iOS version 13.0 & above and Android version 7.0 & above from September 21, 2023 onwards.

     

    Bangkok Bank Mobile Banking

  6. On 1/9/2024 at 11:36 AM, ignis said:

    what I understand from Bangkok Bank, it stopped working on my Android 9 and Android 10 smartphones = had to go into a Branch = still will not work.

     

    REASON they say.. For security, Bangkok Bank Banking can be used with a mobile phone or tablet with supported operating system version 11. or above .. 

     

    I do not need a newer Android phone  !! ?? .

     

    So far NO problem with my SCB app.      just a pain have to go to ATM and transfer money into SCB  to pay water + electric and Internet every month

    It is iOS 11 for APPLE and ANDROID 7 and up for other phones

  7. 1 hour ago, ignis said:

    what I understand from Bangkok Bank, it stopped working on my Android 9 and Android 10 smartphones = had to go into a Branch = still will not work.

     

    REASON they say.. For security, Bangkok Bank Banking can be used with a mobile phone or tablet with supported operating system version 11. or above .. 

     

    I do not need a newer Android phone  !! ?? .

     

    So far NO problem with my SCB app.      just a pain have to go to ATM and transfer money into SCB  to pay water + electric and Internet every month

    Without any specifics I can't really answer, ANDROID is a hard one because it is Open Source. Most (80%) of our customers use ANDROID and the vast majority have no problem. If you look at SCB or KBANK on Play you will see many issues with it not running on certain devices too. 

     

    I would call 1333 to get some more expert help or I would send me your details I can get someone to help you. Please do so ONLY via PM not on this public forum. 

     

    SCB uses FLUTTER for ROBINHOOD which is designed to use a Canvas to prevent such problems, but even that App has problems if you look on PLAY. So as I said, ANDROID is a challenge

     

    We support from ANDROID 7 up I believe. 

  8. On 1/5/2024 at 5:08 PM, Pib said:

    Question regarding adding a new mobile device...or maybe I should say activating Bangkok Bank mbanking on a new phone...I going to upgrade to a new phone over next few months. In the Bangkok Bank mbanking app there is a menu/setting that shows the mobile device you currently have activated to work with the banking and there is a Delete button allowing you to delete that device.

     

    Here's my question: to activate the Bangkok Bank mbanking app on your new phone must I first go into my old phone and delete it in the menu OR by activating the mbanking on the new phone that process will automatically delete the old phone.

     

    In your response above it implies it's an automatic process but I'm not sure.  Thanks.

    Actually I have no idea, let me ask my team. When I did it recently I did not really take note of all the steps but it was really quick. I will ask and get back to you. I used to have 4 or 5 phones registered before this BOT regulation. 

    • Thanks 1
  9. On 11/28/2023 at 8:03 PM, Pib said:

     

    To ensure I understand where you say, "...you can use the app to delete an "old" phone profile...," do you mean deleting the old profile by doing this on the old phone OR doing it from the new phone?   Of course this assumes you still have the old phone and app installed on it.   

     

    In the app under gear icon setting there is a menu titled Application, Device Management which currently shows my phone....I only have the app installed on one phone.  And there is a Delete button next to it which apparently would allow you to delete the device which would probably at the same time stop the ability to log onto the app until you set it up again like with a new phone.

     

     

     

     

    The Bank of Thailand no longer allows banks to provide Mobile Banking on multiple devices. So we need to limit it to one active device. So when you add a new one the old one is deactivated.

    • Thanks 2
  10. On 10/15/2023 at 4:58 PM, KannikaP said:

    Come on, give us a clue. FATCA?

     

    Mr Bingle helped, OK. But the OP was regarding a UK banking app not installing over here.

    FATCA

     

    "The Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA), which was passed as part of the HIRE Act, generally requires that foreign financial Institutions and certain other non-financial foreign entities report on the foreign assets held by their U.S. account holders or be subject to withholding on withholdable payments."

  11. 2 minutes ago, ianguygil said:

    Clearly as a bank we can't talk about exactly what we use or how it works. But there are proprietary solutions which absolutely allow us to see "through" most commercial VPN's. If we can't see through it we will block it. IP is so easy to spoof that we would never rely on it for a location. 

     

    Sorry but I do not mean to be evasive. But you can understand we would never name the exact products that we use. 

    One last point. We do not block access to our websites or our apps from abroad. I use the al the time (tomorrow in fact I will be overseas). But we do block countries with sanctions in place 

  12. On 10/15/2023 at 6:00 PM, topt said:

    genuinely curious - do you mean when the ip address shows from a location that is a commercially known potential hub of a vpn server?

     

    Or are you saying that you can actually identify the original ip address location so basically invalidating the use of a vpn and is this with all or just the less secure vpns? Or some sort of cookie/script function?

    Clearly as a bank we can't talk about exactly what we use or how it works. But there are proprietary solutions which absolutely allow us to see "through" most commercial VPN's. If we can't see through it we will block it. IP is so easy to spoof that we would never rely on it for a location. 

     

    Sorry but I do not mean to be evasive. But you can understand we would never name the exact products that we use. 

  13. 42 minutes ago, Liverpool Lou said:

    How does Schwab apply to the NatWest apps?

    Because somebody was providing details about Vanguard which they noted was a US company. Also I noted that SCHWAB have a pretty good UK presence so it may work for the SHCWAB UK App too. Seems reasonable to me. Maybe not to you.

     

    For those relying on VPN, we have a product which allows us to "see through" VPN. And while we do not block we do know it and it can count in a risk rating. Others do this too. So do not think that most VPN are invisible/transparent. They are not

×
×
  • Create New...