Jump to content

Non-OA health insurance Chaeng Wattan madness


Recommended Posts

15 minutes ago, Mike Teavee said:

I like Vietnam but the 3 month at a time Visa policy worries me more than the 1 year I get in Thailand.

 

You have to ask yourself how long they will continue to allow it if scores of Expats de-camp to there given that Cambodia has been talking about stricter checks on the 1 year "Business Visa" & even Philippines is debating whether to make changes to bar extensions to Visa on Arrival (i.e. the Visas that people from India/China etc... get) 

 

Hardly the basis for a long term retirement plan (I know, neither is Thailand anymore). 

And, oh so strangely, no one even mentions the excellent Malaysian option. M2H is still up, running and well designed, as far as I know.

Is is for lack of cheap p!!!y there? Bacon I managed to get.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, Alotoftravel said:

I have Pacific cross medical policy for my o a extension which also starts at 4:30 PM.

 

I wonder if I will encounter the Same problem here in chiang mai immigration; must have insurance Started prior to the expiry of my visa When i renew, I plan to go 45 days to apply before visa expiry? 

 

I did ask Pacific cross if I should get insurance for “ additional time” before my visa expiry , they Can but there will be no certificate for the extra time which they cannot guarantee that immigration will accept. 

 

Cannot seem to do the right thing nor know when or what is the right thing To do

 

Let us know how it works out 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

47 minutes ago, Momofarang said:

And, oh so strangely, no one even mentions the excellent Malaysian option. M2H is still up, running and well designed, as far as I know.

Is is for lack of cheap p!!!y there? Bacon I managed to get.

Spent 15 months using KL as my base while I traveled around the region & no problem with getting bacon or pork there (some of the best lean pork cuts I've had were from the supermarkets in KL & ridiculously cheap), no problem getting cheap pussy either ???? 

 

But I didn't mention Malaysia as a) It's a lot more expensive than the Thai options & b) It comes with a requirement for Health Insurance (though I believe they will, on a case-by-case basis, wave the requirement & allow you to deposit a bond if none of the insurers will insure you).

 

The Philippines SRRV option is worth a look, by far the friendliest long term stay option & you can get access to Blue Cross health care (queue the "Yeah, but it's the Philippines" comments, I actually like the place, Visayas in particular, but that's just me).

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Alotoftravel said:

I have Pacific cross medical policy for my o a extension which also starts at 4:30 PM.

 

I wonder if I will encounter the Same problem here in chiang mai immigration; must have insurance Started prior to the expiry of my visa When i renew, I plan to go 45 days to apply before visa expiry? 

 

I did ask Pacific cross if I should get insurance for “ additional time” before my visa expiry , they Can but there will be no certificate for the extra time which they cannot guarantee that immigration will accept. 

 

Cannot seem to do the right thing nor know when or what is the right thing To do

 

I discussed this with Aetna and as you say they cannot give a certificate for the stub period coverage because the system only allows them to upload one certificate per customer to Immigration and of course we need the certificate for the extension coverage.   Yet Immigration told me they would allow me to get my extension in advance if I could prove I have coverage in the stub period.  The question is how could I prove that without a certificate?  I didn’t get into that with them but I suspect if you brought your stub period policy and a letter from the insurer (signed original) confirming coverage they might accept that.  If not they are really creating an impossible situation, demanding proof that cannot be given.  I’ve asked Aetna to explore this further and I’ll post what I hear. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Mike Teavee said:

 

But I didn't mention Malaysia as a) It's a lot more expensive than the Thai options & b) It comes with a requirement for Health Insurance (though I believe they will, on a case-by-case basis, wave the requirement & allow you to deposit a bond if none of the insurers will insure you).

 

 

More expensive in that you have to keep more money in a local account than in Thailand?Or ...?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, TerraplaneGuy said:

More expensive in that you have to keep more money in a local account than in Thailand?Or ...?

Yes, the financial requirements (money in bank & income) are much higher than Thailand 

 

edit (apologies, am on my mobile)... 

Malaysia My Second Home program has one of the most stringent financial requirements as compared to retirement visas from other countries. The government places importance on attracting the people who are financially strong to support their stay here.

MM2H Visa Application: Financial Requirements

  1. Applicants below the age of 50 years must provide proof of liquid financial assets or financial strength of at least RM500,000 and an offshore income equivalent to RM10,000 per month. There is no need to transfer any money to Malaysia yet. What is required are bank statements (the three months prior to submission)
  2. Applicants above the age of 50 years must provide proof of liquid financial assets or financial strength of at least RM350,000 and an offshore income equivalent to RM10,000 per month. There is no need to transfer any money to Malaysia yet. What is required are bank statements (the three months prior to submission)
  3. Sources of income: salary, investment returns, government pension, interest, rental of properties, royalty or any other income type earned outside Malaysia. Please let us know how you are going to meet this requirement. Some income may not be monthly income. It can be used but we need to work together on this matter.
  4. Sources of financial strength: Property valuation are not considered. All others are acceptable but you need to let us know what you have.
  5. Upon visa approval and in order for the visa to be stamped on the passport, the participant needs to deposit RM300,000 (below the age of 50) or RM150,000 (above the age of 50) in a bank operating in Malaysia. It will be a bank of his/her choice.

 

1,000 MYR is a little over 7,500 THB 

 

Edited by Mike Teavee
Added financial requirements
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/23/2020 at 1:41 PM, Martyp said:

My problem may be trying to renew my insurance 3 months early. 

That could, indeed, prove problematical as I gather that insurers only invite renewals of existing policies no earlier than 1 month before their expiry date.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/24/2020 at 12:10 PM, Mike Teavee said:

I like Vietnam but the 3 month at a time Visa policy worries me more than the 1 year I get in Thailand.

 

You have to ask yourself how long they will continue to allow it if scores of Expats de-camp to there given that Cambodia has been talking about stricter checks on the 1 year "Business Visa" & even Philippines is debating whether to make changes to bar extensions to Visa on Arrival (i.e. the Visas that people from India/China etc... get) 

 

Hardly the basis for a long term retirement plan (I know, neither is Thailand anymore). 

New Vietnam policy (from 1 July 2020) is 30 days. No more 3 months.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

OP UPDATE:  I've had a lot of discussion with Aetna and they've talked to Immigration about my problem.   Aetna offered to increase my coverage to the required B40,000 OPD for the stub period before my next extension (between now and February 12) so that I can go in advance and extend.  But Immigration said it won't work because they will not accept even a signed certificate from Aetna confirming that.  They will only accept an uploaded certificate as proof, and since Aetna had to upload the certificate for my upcoming extension year already, and the system only takes one per customer, there is no way to upload another.  In other words, Immigration is saying that if I want to apply in advance (as per usual) I have to prove current coverage as well as coverage for the upcoming year, but that is impossible because the system can't show both!  So Immigration is sticking to their position that the only day I can apply is my expiry day, February 12.  And they are sticking to the time requirement, which means I can't apply before 4:30 PM (the time of my policy, and everyone's) when Chaeng Wattana closes.  As a special accommodation, they say they are prepared to have the staff work a few minutes late to get my extension done.  However, I will have to come back another day for my re-entry permit because that office will be closed by the time I have my extension.  I have Aetna's legal team working on the possibility of moving the time of my policy to an earlier time (although the law normally requires 4:30 pm).  I'm not optimistic on that.  Meanwhile what I'm wondering is:

 

1. Will this happen again next year?  If they continue with these rules, even though I will have proper coverage for the then-current year, when I go to apply again for an extension it seems I will run into the same problem:  Aetna will have to upload my new certificate for the upcoming extension year and the previous one will be deleted.  That will prevent me from applying in advance and force me to apply only on my expiry date at 4:30 PM.  That is unless Immigration is smart enough to devise a system of recording or preserving previous year's certificates.  Or doing the rational thing and relying on the fact that if you've already got an extension you met the requirements at that time.  But they're not doing that now so I'm not holding my breath for next year.  And if they don't change their rules, how can I expect them to make a special accommodation for me year after year?  Obviously they won't, so they'll force me to overstay and apply late, breaking the law.

 

2. Why do I seem to be one of only a very few people having this problem?  Are there not many holders of Non-Imm. O-A visas getting extensions?  If there are, why are you all not having this problem of being unable to apply in advance for want of proof of current insurance coverage?  I'd appreciate any input.

Edited by TerraplaneGuy
  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

42 minutes ago, TerraplaneGuy said:

OP UPDATE:  I've had a lot of discussion with Aetna and they've talked to Immigration about my problem.   Aetna offered to increase my coverage to the required B40,000 OPD for the stub period before my next extension (between now and February 12) so that I can go in advance and extend.  But Immigration said it won't work because they will not accept even a signed certificate from Aetna confirming that.  They will only accept an uploaded certificate as proof, and since Aetna had to upload the certificate for my upcoming extension year already, and the system only takes one per customer, there is no way to upload another.  In other words, Immigration is saying that if I want to apply in advance (as per usual) I have to prove current coverage as well as coverage for the upcoming year, but that is impossible because the system can't show both!  So Immigration is sticking to their position that the only day I can apply is my expiry day, February 12.  And they are sticking to the time requirement, which means I can't apply before 4:30 PM (the time of my policy, and everyone's) when Chaeng Wattana closes.  As a special accommodation, they say they are prepared to have the staff work a few minutes late to get my extension done.  However, I will have to come back another day for my re-entry permit because that office will be closed by the time I have my extension.  I have Aetna's legal team working on the possibility of moving the time of my policy to an earlier time (although the law normally requires 4:30 pm).  I'm not optimistic on that.  Meanwhile what I'm wondering is:

 

1. Will this happen again next year?  If they continue with these rules, even though I will have proper coverage for the then-current year, when I go to apply again for an extension it seems I will run into the same problem:  Aetna will have to upload my new certificate for the upcoming extension year and the previous one will be deleted.  That will prevent me from applying in advance and force me to apply only on my expiry date at 4:30 PM.  That is unless Immigration is smart enough to devise a system of recording or preserving previous year's certificates.  Or doing the rational thing and relying on the fact that if you've already got an extension you met the requirements at that time.  But they're not doing that now so I'm not holding my breath for next year.  And if they don't change their rules, how can I expect them to make a special accommodation for me year after year?  Obviously they won't, so they'll force me to overstay and apply late, breaking the law.

 

2. Why do I seem to be one of only a very few people having this problem?  Are there not many holders of Non-Imm. O-A visas getting extensions?  If there are, why are you all not having this problem of being unable to apply in advance for want of proof of current insurance coverage?  I'd appreciate any input.

My Pacific Cross insurance begins January 1st. I originally got my PC insurance before the insurance requirement. If I understand the logic of what is happening to you then I think I will be OK in November if I can get my insurance renewed early enough before November 19th when my extension of stay expires. When I apply I will have an insurance certificate for this year in the database. I will have a certificate for next year, starting January 1, but not yet uploaded to the database. I may have to move my insurance back to December 1 if renewing early becomes a problem. In any case do you see this timing as a possible solution to your situation?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Martyp said:

My Pacific Cross insurance begins January 1st. I originally got my PC insurance before the insurance requirement. If I understand the logic of what is happening to you then I think I will be OK in November if I can get my insurance renewed early enough before November 19th when my extension of stay expires. When I apply I will have an insurance certificate for this year in the database. I will have a certificate for next year, starting January 1, but not yet uploaded to the database. I may have to move my insurance back to December 1 if renewing early becomes a problem. In any case do you see this timing as a possible solution to your situation?

I don't.   The problem is that when you go to extend, say on November 2, your new certificate, for the upcoming year, will not be uploaded.  They will not accept it as proof of coverage.  So they will say come back when it is uploaded.  Changing your policy to December 1 won't change that. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/23/2020 at 5:32 PM, gamini said:

My friend who is 88 would like to spend his last few years in Thailand. He has ample funds for retirement visa deposit and anything else, No insurance company will ensure him at his age . So what happens now

Some posters have suggested that he could apply for the Elite Visa.  That's of course an option when 500K bath for the 5 year Elite Visa is not a big deal for him.

Alternatively, he could simply enter Thailand Visa Exempt or on a Tourist Visa, and then apply for a 90-day Non Imm O - retirement Visa at the IO of the place where he would like to stay.  In the last month of that 90-day period, he can then apply at that same IO for a 1-year extension of stay.

Following the above route he would be in the same situation as applying for an extension of stay at the end of the permission to stay granted by an OA Visa.  But with the important difference that for the Non Imm O - retirement Visa (and extension) NO bogus health-insurance is required.

>>> I did PM you a comprehensive roadmap outlining all details / options when you want to go the Non Imm O - retirement road.

To access your PM-messages just click the letter-icon next to your profile when logged in to the Forum.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 1/22/2020 at 4:12 PM, TerraplaneGuy said:

That's my concern and why I've held off on changing.  

On 1/22/2020 at 4:03 PM, Caldera said:

...

Personally, I think changing to a Non-O visa - while tempting - will lead to a very short-lived victory for those who do it. Now that Thai immigration and insurance companies have created that nice little earner, does anyone really believe that they won't maximize the number of "customers" (victims) in the very near future? I bet it's just around the corner.

I feel for you having read your continuing ordeal at IO with the thai-approved health-insurance policy you bought.

You state that you were aware of the option to change to a Non Imm O - retirement Visa but held off on doing so because you felt the 'O' would be next.  Personally I do not believe that the thai authorities will roll-out the present mandatory health-insurance disaster to other Visa categories anytime soon. 

So given the problems you encountered (and will likely keep on encountering in the future) why not switch to a Non Imm O - retirement Visa.  You can keep your present Aetna health-insurance policy when you are satisfied with it (or dump it, and go for another thai or international health-insurance that meets your needs).

The process to convert to a Non Imm O - retirement Visa is surprisingly simple, and I bet the whole process would have taken you less time and surely less frustration than what you are struggling with now.

I have PM-ed you a comprehensive roadmap outlining all details/options on how to do it.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, TerraplaneGuy said:

I don't.   The problem is that when you go to extend, say on November 2, your new certificate, for the upcoming year, will not be uploaded.  They will not accept it as proof of coverage.  So they will say come back when it is uploaded.  Changing your policy to December 1 won't change that. 

I will just have to go to CW later in the year and have a discussion about what they will accept at that time. You seem to presenting a situation where no one can get an extension unless they are there at 4:30pm on the day it expires. Obviously that is not the case for many people who have obtained extension for the last couple of months. 

  • Confused 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Martyp said:

I will just have to go to CW later in the year and have a discussion about what they will accept at that time. You seem to presenting a situation where no one can get an extension unless they are there at 4:30pm on the day it expires. Obviously that is not the case for many people who have obtained extension for the last couple of months. 

Yes, that is exactly what I've been told repeatedly by Immigration escalating up several levels of seniority.  Aetna was told the same thing when they inquired.  I agree it makes no sense and I'd like to hear from anyone with a Non-OA who has recently extended at CW about their experience.  Could it be that not many people have these visas anymore?

Edited by TerraplaneGuy
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, TerraplaneGuy said:

Welcome to the club.  Tell us, when they said come back on the day of your expiry did they say anything about the TIME?  As I've mentioned, with me they said they couldn't issue an extension before not only the day but the TIME that the new policy took effect, which is (I am told by Aetna) always, by law, 4:30 PM (check your certificate, you'll see) and therefore means extension is impossible unless they make a special accommodation to work with you past closing time which of course is 4:30 PM.  I doubt even the North Koreans could get that stupid.

No thankfully it was just "come back tomorrow."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, TerraplaneGuy said:

So you already got it?  And what time did they issue your extension?

I completed the procedure in the morning but I have just checked my policy and in fact it is timed later that day so perhaps in hindsight I was lucky to get out of the building while being in the country uninsured with no medical cover for 4 hours. 

  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

OP Update: On my second trip to CW (yesterday) I finally got my extension, a few days before expiry of my current one.  It took a creative solution from Aetna and the intervention of an Inspector/Superintendent at Immigration.  Not a solution that is going to apply in other cases, unfortunately.  But Aetna is working with the TGIA (Thai General Insurance Association, which liaises with Immigration on this) to try to find a general fix.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.





×
×
  • Create New...