Jump to content

More than 100,000 foreigners staying illegally in Thailand


webfact

Recommended Posts

If they want rid of farang overstayers, declare an amnesty for 90 days, then after that make the daily fine unlimited. There's people here that are happy to pay the 20,000 baht on exit and overstay by years. They judge the risk of being caught against the aggro of getting visas. If the fine was unlimited, they'd leave. The sane one's would anyway.

So instead of a policy to deal with this problem, they'll punish all the honest people with a 500 baht charge.

Absurd

It is a sham, just like how they said before to levy money to pay for foreigners that stay in hospitals and don't pay their bill. So then the good guys ware paying for healthcare without entitlement to it. They are just looking for an excuse to rip the tourist even more off as already. Mind you there is already a departing tax in tickets before you had to pay that separate. So this is just an addition.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • Replies 287
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Nobody here said 100.000 European / American / Australian foreigners I dare say it will be mostly people from neighboring countries.

Agreed. Many of whom are brought over by Thai mafia/gangs (with Govt connections I would assume) to work illiegally here. They'll just add the 500 Baht to the 'debt' these migrant workers have to work off.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Nobody knows how many illegal immigrants there are in Thailand, and probably least of all the Government departments that are supposed to know. All the numbers presented by these twits are random figures they dream up to make a case for their next 'innovative' idea about how to extract more cash from visitors to this country.

Link to post
Share on other sites

If they want rid of farang overstayers, declare an amnesty for 90 days, then after that make the daily fine unlimited. There's people here that are happy to pay the 20,000 baht on exit and overstay by years. They judge the risk of being caught against the aggro of getting visas. If the fine was unlimited, they'd leave. The sane one's would anyway.

So instead of a policy to deal with this problem, they'll punish all the honest people with a 500 baht charge.

Absurd

It is a sham, just like how they said before to levy money to pay for foreigners that stay in hospitals and don't pay their bill. So then the good guys ware paying for healthcare without entitlement to it. They are just looking for an excuse to rip the tourist even more off as already. Mind you there is already a departing tax in tickets before you had to pay that separate. So this is just an addition.

I can see it's a sham, they've done nothing about the overstay problem.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just wonder where did they get those figures .. 100,000 foreigners illegal ... and how many illegals in European countries ? in the US ? this 500 baht will only be used to fill up some pockets of greedy politicians ... they call is government funding ! cheesy.gif

Based upon the OP we are talking about visa overstay. As an example in the UK it is claimed there are approx. 150,000 visa over stayers identified at any one time. In Australia it’s approx 54,000 at any one time, with the majority being from Europe together with 1,000+ Thais.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-23187320

http://www.immi.gov.au/media/fact-sheets/86overstayers-and-other-unlawful-non-citizens.htm

Link to post
Share on other sites

If they want rid of farang overstayers, declare an amnesty for 90 days, then after that make the daily fine unlimited. There's people here that are happy to pay the 20,000 baht on exit and overstay by years. They judge the risk of being caught against the aggro of getting visas. If the fine was unlimited, they'd leave. The sane one's would anyway.

So instead of a policy to deal with this problem, they'll punish all the honest people with a 500 baht charge.

Absurd

What a refreshing change...​Instead of the boringly predictable TV whatever...he is a very sound solution that would flush the toilet nicely for both sides.

The foreigners get a chance to make it all good with a fresh start, and the Government also gets a fresh start, as in...we gave you a chance to fix this...now the fines are unlimited.

The 20,000 cap was simply an invitation to say, If you intend to stay for years, do not want the visa run hassle, can do a bit of math to see where the break even point is...then of course...it is not "good person, bad person" ... it is "Can do math, can not do math."

What an easy and elegant solution, "theblehter", well done.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Once again the classic Thai definition of quality = rich(er). Those who can afford to pay must be of better 'quality' as they are richer.

Perhaps we shouldn't be surprised by this rather simplistic and crude definition of 'quality' as it pervades most parts of Thai society; Fat Somchai buys (on credit?) the best 'quality phone, tablet, car, etc. which he can purchase, this now implies that Fat Somchai is now materially and socially superior to Thin Somchai who has last years model. And is more correct about all things worldly as he is clearly of better quality (aka class).

And that is what this boils down to social snobbery and greed, based on an archaic system of social steroetyping where your 'worth' is defined by how fat your wallet is.

The sad irony is those who are worthless aka the poor farmers, voted the people that maintain this system into power, on the promise that they would enrich them and make them part of the 'quality' system, or in other words - make them like Fat Somchai so they wouldn't have to be Thin Somchai anymore. And time and time again they buy it.

This concept is now being applied to Tourists. Expect this to become law.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Quality tourists and reducing overstayers through a 500 baht fee...the answer was so simple...I feel so stupid now. And just think, if the govt raises the fee to 1,000 they could also solve poverty in Thailand (they'll think of that next month). Better living through fees.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Perhaps the overstay-tourists are all waiting somewhere in-the-queue, to get to the Immigration-desk at their local office, to try to extend their stay ? My local office is way over-stretched !

And don't these tourists on overstay also contribute, like the Indian/Russian/Chinese budget-hordes, to the Thai economy, by eating/drinking/staying-somewhere ?

The simplest way, to cut the overstay-problem (if indeed it is a problem), is to give a 90-day Visa-On-Arrival ! rolleyes.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

All the numbers presented by these twits are random figures they dream up to make a case for their next 'innovative' idea about how to extract more cash from visitors to this country.

They not looking for "quality" tourists by adding a another charge on top of visa fees. They are looking for STUPID tourists.

Link to post
Share on other sites

So instead of a policy to deal with this problem, they'll punish all the honest people with a 500 baht charge.

It is a sham, just like how they said before to levy money to pay for foreigners that stay in hospitals and don't pay their bill. So then the good guys ware paying for healthcare without entitlement to it. They are just looking for an excuse to rip the tourist even more off as already.

These comments are precisely the problem with this government proposal. The problems with foreigners not paying hospital bill is only a very small minority, and hospitals can easily cope with those losses like any well run business allow for some customers that can't pay. Otherwise they need to change their own payment policy by charging up front.

Also robblok has a good point. It seems like they are just looking for any excuse to get legitimately get more money from 20 million tourists. If it wasn''t the hospital bills, they would justify by saying too many foreigners are committing crimes and clogging up the courts and police time. Or causing environmental degradation on beaches , or contributing to much traffic jams. It's always the vote winner to blame the foreigners

Link to post
Share on other sites

And how 500 baht, pray-tell, will prevent foreigners from over saying?

Would a 'bad quality foreigner /tourist' will be deterred from entering

the kingdom just because he has to pay 500 baht?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...