Jump to content

Police reveal how Phuket's public beaches were rented out - for billions


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 148
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

but the other side tourist need sun beds and umbrellas. so someone have to rent.

They should do the same as other countries and rent out the beach with control on prices and the money goes to central/local government - not the mayor's pocket.

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

Wade72 raises a rational point. The “discovery” by investigators about the money involved in the renting out of beach space on Karon and Kata beaches may not be as scandalous as it seems.

Wade : “If the money had gone into public coffers in the first place there would be no corruption charges at this point.”

“… most municipal governments generally can issue permits, and charge for the permits, to operate businesses on public land when they can show it is in the publics interest.”

In this case the “Municipality would allocate a sunbed operator space in front of the resort.” It would seem that if the Municipality does have authority (either explicit or implicit by the lack of such prohibition), is transparent about the transactions (ie., public notice, municipal council review), and follows proper public procurement procedures (ie., competitive bidding, fair value), then such transaction should be treated as legal. If the Mayor keeps the transaction secret, has a conflict of interest with operators/hotel owners, and/or embezzles the receipts, he has probably committed one or more criminal offenses but that does not incriminate the transaction.

Having an exclusive legal license, the sunbed operator is then within his legal right to transact with the adjacent hotel for exclusive right to the operator services for which a fee would be proper. If the operator has a conflict of interest with the hotel, and/or fails to report income for tax purposes, he has probably committed one or more criminal offenses but that does not incriminate the transaction.

The Municipality can choose now not to renew such licenses (cancellation may result in costly breach of contract to the operators and lawsuits by the hotels). But obviously, the hotel owners and their guests might be upset for the lack of sunbed services (perhaps even advertised by the hotels to attract bookings) that might result in future lost bookings.

Before the law enforcement authorities get too far ahead of themselves, they should examine the whole picture before charging people and hotel owners with breaches of law. If corruption is pursued frivolously, driven by a mindset for accolades, the enforcement body becomes ethically and morally broken.

where to start with such apologetic nonsense
Link to post
Share on other sites

<script type='text/javascript'>window.mod_pagespeed_start = Number(new Date());</script>

but the other side tourist need sun beds and umbrellas. so someone have to rent.

They should do the same as other countries and rent out the beach with control on prices and the money goes to central/local government - not the mayor's pocket.

Get rid of the unsightly umbrellas and uncomfortable beach chairs and most of all the rip off people running the place. Pattaya beach looks like a garbage dump. It would be a big plus for the General if he cleaned up the beaches. Not holding my breath though.

Link to post
Share on other sites

And another big head line from the NCPO, I donot understand what is the real problem.

Even if the local entrepreneurs would send contributions to Bangkok, what is the chance that that money would end up in the state's coffers?

To my belief the biggest thieves are located in BKK.

In the stock market there is a word for this kind of practice, it is called 'window dressing'.

We are to believe the Army is really stepping up against corruption in this country by issuing campaigns and releasing press statements regarding their clamping down on airport taxi maffia, on mini-van maffia at the Victory monument, on tuk-tuk and motor bike gangs, beach vendors etc.....yeah right!

The amounts of money being stolen by these controlled gangs come nowhere near the amounts diappearing at government level, as in the Ministry of the Interior, Transport, Education, shall I go on?

This country will never change in my opinion and if you really want to live in a South Asian country that is well managed and almost free of corruption, you should move to Singapore where a fried rice with chicken or a nice drink at a cool bar costs ten times more than it does here, if you catch my drift.

Link to post
Share on other sites

"...Yutthana’s sunbeds, umbrellas, and other furniture were seized when he was arrested. He asked the court for their return. The judge said no."

cheesy.gif cheesy.gifcheesy.gifcheesy.gifcheesy.gif

What an arrogant fool. facepalm.gif

Well, perhaps let him keep one.

For his cell.

The definition of organized crime.

But, no mafia on the islands... wai2.gifwai.gif

Link to post
Share on other sites

I see hope in Thailand under Junta, might be a historical moment for Thailand. Never knows

Keep on dreaming!

Never heard of that bomb detector fraud scandal, did you?

While it was already clear that it was a big and very expensive scam and the product was nothing more than a useless joy-stick sold for hundreds of thousands baht per piece, they were still ordering some more devices....quite historical indeed.

See also:

http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/jan/26/fraudster-paid-government-promote-fake-bomb-detectors

http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-23768203

Edited by luckyman
Link to post
Share on other sites

today in pattaya the police and military were measuring beach vendors spaces,the vendors were noticably ''pissed'' i was told the rows of chairs and umberellas which sometimes are 5 deep,will be reduced to (2) rows per section..as we know on high tide it is impossible to walk the beach as the vendors take up all the space....this is terrific news.....sawadee (love the crap)

I totally applaud the actions and intent of the gov't doing this for: 1. trying to stamp out the nationwide ethic of corruption that is rampant and entrenched into society and 2. giving back some of the power and pleasure to ordinary citizens and tourists not looking to be scammed.

Now I am wondering when will the inevitable violent backlash happen? Let's hope it doesn't.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.


×
×
  • Create New...